Guild, I need help deciding.

[Zphal]

Hiddochi wolf

I like the complexity of the first one better.

Azmaria

They're both really nice, but I like the first one the most.

GLJordan

second one

Thanks for your input, y'all. smile  

[Zphal]

FoxKin56

Wait...I'm in a guild'?
(It has been a long time since last login, previously Ryu_Noki)

Haha! Surprise! xd  

[Frogsnack]

Depends on the purpose. Honestly the first one is more striking and decorous, the second seems more like a normal tile that could be repeated without taking over a space. Ideally both could be used in the same wall or floor to add interest.  

[Kiba Ryuun]

Second looks cleaner, but not as striking as the first.

If it's to be a tile for the walls/floor, then the second.

If it's to be the main focus/icon of something, go with the first.

Personally liking the first more.  

[playboy_bunny964]

No longer viewable.  

[Necro Skeletal]

Zphal

Necro Skeletal

I'm leaning toward the first, but what's the application? I think that will really be a deciding factor. Without any knowledge of intended use you could go with either one. And can we see them without the grid?

It's gonna be a tree skirt. My partner's genetically Jewish and though his whole family is athiest, they chose to sometimes celebrate Hanukkah and other times celebrate Christmas. I got invited, so I wanted to make something special.

Option 1, and here's why:
I just noticed your other stars. When you have 2 stars in each space, it's cluttered and they don't stand out as much because they feel a little bit free-floating/crammed in there. In option one you have a better repeating pattern. The white star in the middle, the gold star, and then the alternating color stars, which nested neatly in the spaces that the gold star created. That design feels more controlled, and makes appropriate use of the space for each geometric block and is satisfying to look at.

Also, that's an incredibly nice gesture op!  

[DruidTigeress]

They both pretty, but I like the first one best  

[Mama Ame]

First.

BFF has spoken. All other opinions on here are irrelevant.

j/k.  

[Zphal]

Mama Ame

First.

BFF has spoken. All other opinions on here are irrelevant.

j/k.

rofl Well, I do wield the all-mighty ban-hammer.  

[Zphal]

DruidTigeress

They both pretty, but I like the first one best

Thank you! ^__^ I pieced together the first 32 triangles this morning. 3nodding  

[Zphal]

Necro Skeletal

Zphal

Necro Skeletal

I'm leaning toward the first, but what's the application? I think that will really be a deciding factor. Without any knowledge of intended use you could go with either one. And can we see them without the grid?

It's gonna be a tree skirt. My partner's genetically Jewish and though his whole family is athiest, they chose to sometimes celebrate Hanukkah and other times celebrate Christmas. I got invited, so I wanted to make something special.

Option 1, and here's why:
I just noticed your other stars. When you have 2 stars in each space, it's cluttered and they don't stand out as much because they feel a little bit free-floating/crammed in there. In option one you have a better repeating pattern. The white star in the middle, the gold star, and then the alternating color stars, which nested neatly in the spaces that the gold star created. That design feels more controlled, and makes appropriate use of the space for each geometric block and is satisfying to look at.

Also, that's an incredibly nice gesture op!

Now that's an analysis! I'm glad I made the right decision and cut the 3" triangles! xd

His mom's a quilter too and she said if I came, she'd make me a stocking. redface I wanna impress her so she'll accept me as worthy of her son. lol  

[Necro Skeletal]

Zphal

Necro Skeletal

Zphal

Necro Skeletal

I'm leaning toward the first, but what's the application? I think that will really be a deciding factor. Without any knowledge of intended use you could go with either one. And can we see them without the grid?

It's gonna be a tree skirt. My partner's genetically Jewish and though his whole family is athiest, they chose to sometimes celebrate Hanukkah and other times celebrate Christmas. I got invited, so I wanted to make something special.

Option 1, and here's why:
I just noticed your other stars. When you have 2 stars in each space, it's cluttered and they don't stand out as much because they feel a little bit free-floating/crammed in there. In option one you have a better repeating pattern. The white star in the middle, the gold star, and then the alternating color stars, which nested neatly in the spaces that the gold star created. That design feels more controlled, and makes appropriate use of the space for each geometric block and is satisfying to look at.

Also, that's an incredibly nice gesture op!

Now that's an analysis! I'm glad I made the right decision and cut the 3" triangles! xd

His mom's a quilter too and she said if I came, she'd make me a stocking. redface I wanna impress her so she'll accept me as worthy of her son. lol

I'm sure she'll love it! Anything hand made with this much thought put into it is a great gift.  

[Shallow Carnage]

Not to derail this thread but.. more people have posted here so far then I have seen anywhere else in the guild in the last 5 years eek  

[Zphal]

Shallow Carnage

Not to derail this thread but.. more people have posted here so far then I have seen anywhere else in the guild in the last 5 years eek

That's what happens when you abuse your power and send out a guild announcement. rofl